The worries
The same worries come up every time
Every town that has done this heard the same things first: traffic will back up for miles, the shops will die, the fire trucks won't get through, drivers will race down our side streets. These worries are common, and they are reasonable. Time and time again, they have also proved to be unfounded. Here is what was said before, and what was found after.
“Traffic will back up for miles”
Before · Milton, Massachusetts
Route 28 was a four-lane road through neighbourhoods with a crash history, and residents warned that taking a lane would jam the intersections and push commuters onto the side streets.
Raised through the autumn 2025 pilot, at listening sessions and Select Board meetings
After · Milton, Massachusetts
“I live on that road. It’s dramatically better… It’s very successful, and I’ve heard from a lot of people that they love it… You’ve got to deal with traffic, I understand that. It’s just a safer road.”
John Driscoll, Milton Select Board, May 2026. MassDOT kept the road diet: injury crashes down, speeds down 6 to 8 mph
Before · Lawyers Road, Reston, Virginia
At the community meetings before VDOT restriped the road, residents raised “concerns regarding potential traffic congestion” and doubted the bike lanes were needed.
After · Lawyers Road, Reston, Virginia
VDOT went back and asked the neighbours. 69% said travel times had not increased — even though 59% said speeds had dropped. 69% said the road seemed safer, and 74% agreed the project had improved it. Crashes fell 70%.
VDOT community survey, autumn 2010, and its five-year safety study
Before · Barton Springs Road, Austin
Those opposing the project “raised concerns about potential traffic congestion. They fear that reducing lanes could result in gridlock on a crucial artery.”
After · Barton Springs Road, Austin
“A much safer street, lower risk for everybody involved, including drivers and people outside of vehicles. And [we were] able to do that with minimal operational impacts.” Drivers going over 40 mph fell 65%, about 500 fewer a day.
Lewis Leff, assistant director, Austin Transportation and Public Works, May 2024
Before · Prospect Park West, Brooklyn
Opponents were sure enough that taking a lane would jam the street that they took the city’s transportation department to court to have the redesign ripped out.
Before · Merrimon Avenue, Asheville
A petition signed by nearly 900 people said the conversion was “creating backups, delays, safety issues, and driving more traffic onto residential streets.” A shop owner on the avenue called the drive “horrible, it’s literally horrible.”
“Save Merrimon Ave Before It’s Too Late,” and Frank Dosier of the Musician’s Workshop, November 2022
“It will kill the shops”
Before · Ingersoll Avenue, Des Moines, Iowa
“Business owners were evenly split between those who thought the changes would hurt their business and those that thought business would increase.”
Before · East Boulevard, Charlotte, North Carolina
A commuter route carrying 16,000 to 21,400 vehicles a day through a historic district of shops, cafes and homes, with 85th-percentile speeds of 43 mph on a 35-mph street and some drivers doing 50 to 70. The neighbourhood plan asked for a “main street.”
Charlotte ran traffic simulations first, then converted the first stretch from four lanes to three in 2006
After · East Boulevard, Charlotte, North Carolina
“Travel times in the corridor remained constant” and “outdoor dining significantly increased along the corridor after project implementation.” Asked afterwards whether to carry the four-to-three conversion through the last stretch, 77% of those surveyed said yes.
Project for Public Spaces, on the first two phases. Respondents “touted the increased safety of the road for drivers, bicyclists, and pedestrians.” Phase III was built in 2011
Before · Hillsborough Street, Raleigh
Two hundred businesses lined the street, and even the people leading the project expected them to suffer: “It will be uncomfortable while it’s going on, even painful. We’ll work hard to see the businesses that start out here stay here.”
George Chapman, president of the Hillsborough Street Partnership, as construction began in 2009. The idea, he said, had been “not easily accepted in the general community”
After · Hillsborough Street, Raleigh
Four lanes became two, with roundabouts, on-street parking and wider sidewalks. Vehicle crashes fell 23%, and new private investment along the corridor rose from $150 million to $200 million.
Project for Public Spaces’ case study. Sidewalk mileage along the corridor has nearly doubled since 2013
Before · Route 62, Village of Hamburg, New York
Worried about future congestion, NYSDOT proposed rebuilding the village’s main street to carry more traffic: wider lanes, a third lane, and much of the on-street parking gone. A lifelong resident asked, “What are you doing with the trees and the people?” She said state officials told her: “We have to get the traffic through.”
Susan Burns, quoted in The New York Times, on NYSDOT’s original plan in the early 2000s
After · Route 62, Village of Hamburg, New York
“Our entire village is transformed. Not a day goes by in my store I don’t hear about how everyone loves our village. This project fulfilled every expectation and then some.”
Laura Hackathorn, village trustee. The village voted 4–1 for traffic calming over widening, and NYSDOT built it: crashes down 57%, serious injuries down 90%, speeds from 30 to 19 mph, and the street still carries 500 to 600 heavy trucks a day. Commercial building permits in the village rose from 16 in 2005 to 96 in 2010, and property values along the corridor more than doubled. NYSDOT’s own verdict: the project “has the potential to have far-reaching and positive effects on the quality of life for village residents”
Before · Edgewater Drive, Orlando
The fear was gridlock and diversion, and at first it looked founded. When the lane came out, weekday traffic fell from 20,500 vehicles a day to 18,100 — drivers “taking another route out of fear of increased congestion.” Some called for the street to be put back to four lanes.
FHWA on Orlando’s before-and-after study, and the city’s own public process
After · Edgewater Drive, Orlando
The corridor gained 77 new businesses and 560 jobs. Property values rose 80% alongside the street and 70% within half a mile. Collisions fell 40% and injuries 71%; traffic dipped 12% and then returned to its old level.
When Edgewater Drive was resurfaced again in 2012, stakeholders “made no requests to restore Edgewater to a four-lane road”
Sometimes the shops ask for it. In Maplewood, New Jersey the push to narrow Springfield Avenue came from the township’s Economic Development Commission, as part of a strategy to revive the business district and raise property values. The aim was to slow the traffic and make the avenue a “handsome and walkable ‘boulevard.’”
“Fire trucks and ambulances won't get through”
This is the worry that stops projects, and the one with the clearest answer: the center turn lane gives responders a lane nobody else is in.
Before · Woodbury, New Jersey
Woodbury Police were “initially opposed, citing concerns over potentially slower emergency response times.”
Before · Ocean City, New Jersey
There was “skepticism from emergency responders and the public” before the change on West Avenue, the main route for emergency vehicles.
Before · Main Street, Asbury Park, New Jersey
The city opposed NJDOT’s plan for its own main street, citing summer tourist traffic, buses and loading zones, and “how emergency responders would traverse along the narrowed roadway.”
The Asbury Park Sun, on the city’s objection to the state’s road diet, 2017
After · Main Street, Asbury Park, New Jersey
“It all goes back to public safety. The City wouldn’t commit to this plan until our police department, our fire department, DPW, OEM, and Planning were all on board. It is worth trying and this plan will not affect public safety.”
Mayor John Moor, once the city had taken its emergency departments’ concerns to NJDOT, asked for more traffic counts, and had the design changed. NJDOT has since built the road diet
“Drivers will cut through our side streets”
Before · West Hartford, Connecticut
Neighbors north of Fern Street feared that drivers pushed off North Main Street would race through the residential streets instead.
After · West Hartford, Connecticut
“The level of diversion to other roadways has not been significant.” The town counted, and the trial was made permanent that month: “Based on the results … the trial has achieved all of our objectives.”
Greg Sommer, town engineer, and acting town manager Rick Ledwith, June 2022. The objectives were fewer crashes, lower speeds and better access for people walking and biking
Before · Stone Way, Seattle
“We need the road. We need to move traffic, particularly trucks. It’s not a good idea to narrow the street down because traffic will overflow on other streets. This is our arterial. We want the four lanes of traffic.”
Suzie Burke, a Fremont business owner with property on Stone Way, in The Seattle Times, October 12, 2006
After · Stone Way, Seattle
“Motor vehicle traffic has not diverted to neighborhood streets. Daily traffic counts on parallel streets are down by 12 to 34 percent.” Peak-hour volume fell about 5%, so capacity held; top-end speeding fell more than 80% and pedestrian collisions fell 80%.
SDOT’s before-and-after study, 2010. FHWA files the case under “despite early opposition, Road Diet produces great results”
Sometimes the critics say it themselves
Des Moines put a two-mile road diet on Ingersoll Avenue in 2010 as a six-month trial, on a street carrying 11,000 to 17,000 vehicles a day, and promised to put the four lanes back if the objections proved right. Crashes fell by half, traffic volumes did not drop, and the city council voted to keep it. The local paper had opposed it.
Before · North Main Street, West Hartford
A former client told the lawyer Scott Franklin, a few years earlier, that the idea of a road diet on North Main Street was “the dumbest thing ever.”
Recounted by Franklin, a past chair of the town’s Pedestrian and Bicycle Commission
After · North Main Street, West Hartford
He recently heard from that former client, who apologized. “It’s a great testament that our town has bought into this. It’s real change, and it’s a change definitely for the positive.”
At the public information session on the trial, April 2022. A resident of the street put it another way: “I no longer feel like I’m going to die when I’m walking or mowing my lawn”
Sources
- FHWA, “Road Diets and Emergency Response: Friends, Not Foes,” Road Diet Myth Busters, December 2016 (FHWA-SA-17-020)Case studies of West Avenue, Ocean City, NJ, and South Broad Street, Woodbury, NJ, with the quotations from Sgt. Brian Hopely and retired Chief Reed Merinuk.rosap.ntl.bts.gov
- VHB for the Town of West Hartford, “North Main Street Road Diet Study, Phase 2, Final Report,” June 2022Cut-through counts, the emergency services review, and the diversion figures for Trout Brook Drive.Report (PDF)
- Newton, “Feedback on Road Diet Largely Positive at Public Information Session,” We-Ha, May 5, 2022About 75 people attended the April 28 session on the North Main Street trial, and more than a dozen spoke. Scott Franklin’s account of the former client who called the idea “the dumbest thing ever” and later apologised; residents Matt Warshauer and Isaac Kamola on living on the street. VHB’s Joe Balskus said more than 200 comments had been logged, a majority supportive, that crash data was reduced, and that concerns about cut-through traffic “we think that has abated.”We-Ha
- We-Ha, “West Hartford to Make North Main Street Road Diet Permanent,” June 2022We-Ha
- MyRye, “Traffic & Pedestrian Safety in Rye with Brian Dempsey,” MyRye.com Conversations with Doug French, August 2026The road diet discussion starts at 12:35.YouTube
- Rye crash comparison, compiled by Mamaroneck and Rye Neck Safe Routes to SchoolBefore: crash counts by location in Buckhurst Fish & Jacquemart’s Boston Post Road Design Feasibility Study for the City of Rye, July 2007, covering 2004–06. After: NYSDOT crash records, 2012–14. Corridor-wide, 86 crashes fell to 28; at the Osborn Road intersection, 24 fell to 1.The Rye example
- FHWA, Road Diet Case Studies: Lawyers Road, Reston, VirginiaA 2-mile VDOT conversion on a road carrying about 10,000 vehicles a day, done with a scheduled repaving. Concerns raised at the community meetings; the autumn 2010 survey results; a 70% crash reduction over five years. Survey report: “Lawyers Road Diet Survey Results Report,” December 2010.FHWA
- Project for Public Spaces, “Prospect Park West: Overcoming Controversy to Improve Safety and Mobility in Brooklyn,” summarising NYC DOT’s monitoringOne travel lane removed from a three-lane one-way street in June 2010 for a protected two-way bikeway. Speeding fell from 74% of vehicles to 20% and average speeds from 33.8 to 26.6 mph; crashes down 16% and injury crashes down 63%; injuries to all street users down 21%, with no reported pedestrian injuries in the after period; peak volumes and travel times stable; combined vehicle and bicycle counts up 13% in the morning peak. The residents’ lawsuit was dismissed.PPS · NYC DOT
- Bernier, “Breaking down Austin’s experiment on Barton Springs Road,” KUT, July 20, 2023; Stark, “Data suggests Barton Springs Road is safer following pilot project,” KXAN, May 20, 2024A 12-month pilot from August 2023 taking Barton Springs Road from two lanes to one in each direction, with physically separated bicycle lanes. Drivers travelling over 40 mph on a 30-mph street fell 65%, roughly 500 fewer a day. Quotation from Lewis Leff of Austin Transportation and Public Works.KUT · KXAN · City of Austin
- James, “‘It’s horrible’: Merrimon Avenue changes prompt online petition with hundreds of signatures,” WLOS, November 1, 2022The petition “Save Merrimon Ave Before It’s Too Late” and Frank Dosier, owner of the Musician’s Workshop on Merrimon Avenue, while the conversion was under construction.WLOS
- NCDOT safety and mobility summary reports on the Merrimon Avenue 4-to-3 conversion, June 2024 and August 2026; City of Asheville project pageTotal crashes down 24% and injury crashes down 6%; vehicle speeds reduced; bicycle traffic up, with a sharp rise in the share riding in the road rather than on the sidewalk. The conversion ran from W.T. Weaver Boulevard to Midland Road and was completed in May 2024.City of Asheville
- Tan, “Going on A Road Diet,” FHWA Public Roads, Vol. 75 No. 2, September/October 2011 (FHWA-HRT-11-006)Edgewater Drive, Orlando: average daily traffic of 20,000 at the time; volumes fell from 20,500 to 18,100 and then rose to 21,000; crash rates down 34% and injury rates down 68%; pedestrians up 23% and bicyclists up 30%. Also Stone Way North, Seattle, and the Vancouver, Washington and Athens, Georgia case studies presented to the Institute of Transportation Engineers in 2005. Quotations from Peter Lagerwey, former coordinator of Seattle’s pedestrian and bicycle program. The underlying Orlando study is City of Orlando, “Edgewater Drive Before & After Re-Striping Results,” Transportation Planning Bureau, 2002.Public Roads
- MassDOT, Milton Route 28 Road Diet Pilot; Zamora, “Road diet deemed a success, roundabout work to begin,” Milton Times, June 4, 2026Randolph Avenue from Reedsdale Road to Chickatawbut Road, four lanes to two with two-way left-turn lanes, implemented October 2025 and evaluated through spring 2026. MassDOT deemed the pilot a success and kept it: injury crashes down, speeds down 6 to 8 mph, weekday volumes on Route 28 down by roughly 3,000 to 5,000 vehicles. Cut-through traffic on side streets rose, drawing retimed signals and a weekday afternoon no-left-turn restriction. About 50 positive and 20 negative comments from residents. Quotations from Kayla Sousa of MassDOT and Select Board member John Driscoll at the May 26, 2026 meeting.MassDOT · Milton Times
- Ewing and King, “Flexible Design of New Jersey’s Main Streets,” Alan M. Voorhees Transportation Center, Rutgers, for NJDOT, 2002Case study 3.2.1, Maplewood, pages 51–57: the Economic Development Commission’s strategy, the “handsome and walkable ‘boulevard’” aim, NJDOT’s cone-and-marking trial, and the level-of-service table.Report (PDF)
- Gladden, “Main Street Road Diet Is Back,” Asbury Park Sun, May 22, 2017NJDOT proposed taking the state-owned Main Street from four lanes to two with a bicycle lane and a two-way turn lane. The city opposed it over emergency access, transit and loading, then took its emergency departments’ concerns to NJDOT and requested more traffic counts. The revised plan went ahead as a two-year pilot. Deputy Mayor Amy Quinn and Mayor John Moor are quoted; Moor also noted that “it’s paint, it can be changed back.”Asbury Park Sun
- FHWA, Road Diet Case Studies: Stone Way, Seattle, WashingtonQuoting local business owners from S. Gilmore, “City Wants to Put Four-Lane Stone Way on Road Diet,” The Seattle Times, October 12, 2006, and SDOT’s 2010 before-and-after study.FHWA
- Project for Public Spaces, “Realizing a Community’s Vision for East Boulevard”Charlotte, North Carolina. 1.5 miles in three phases: four lanes to three in 2006, five lanes to three in 2010, and four to three in 2011, each with a two-way left-turn lane, pedestrian refuge islands and bike lanes. 16,000 to 21,400 vehicles a day. Travel times stayed constant through phases I and II while 85th-percentile speeds fell from 43 to 40 mph on a 35-mph street. Average daily traffic fell from about 20,500 to 17,500 in the phase I area and rose from about 18,600 to 19,700 in the phase II area. Outdoor dining increased. After phases I and II, 77% of respondents to a public survey wanted the four-to-three conversion carried through phase III. Charlotte DOT ran Synchro simulations beforehand.PPS
- Steuteville, “Bigger is not better for main street,” CNU Public Square, January 30, 2018A case study written for the Institute of Transportation Engineers’ Implementing Context Sensitive Design on Multimodal Corridors, funded by FHWA. NYSDOT’s original plan widened lanes from 11 to 12 feet, added an 11-foot turn lane and removed considerable on-street parking. Susan Burns’s account of what state officials told her is quoted from The New York Times. Ten-foot travel lanes with four-foot coloured buffers and seven-foot parking lanes; about 11,000 vehicles a day; $23 million project cost; $800,000 in state façade grants leveraging more than $7 million of private investment in 33 buildings; commercial building permits up from 16 in 2005 to 96 in 2010; injury crashes down 60% and serious injuries down 90% in a police analysis. The NYSDOT quotation dates from the 2010 America’s Transportation Award.CNU
- Project for Public Spaces, “Road Diet Case Study: Rethinking Route 62”Completed 2009. Four roundabouts, coloured buffer lanes, mid-block crossings, more on-street parking and street trees on a US route that doubles as the village main street. Crashes down 57%, injuries down 60%, serious injuries down 90%; driving speeds from 30 mph to 19 mph; 500 to 600 heavy freight trucks a day still carried. The village voted 4–1 for the traffic-calming plan over NYSDOT’s widening. Quotations from village trustee Laura Hackathorn and from NYSDOT, via an Institute of Transportation Engineers report. Hamburg won an America’s Transportation Award in the 2010 Northeast regional competition.PPS
- Project for Public Spaces, “Edgewater Drive: Improving Safety and Supporting a Main Street”1.5 miles in Orlando’s College Park, restriped in 2002 from four lanes to three with bike lanes. On the public process: the public asked for the before-and-after measurements, and some called for reversion once it was built. On-street parking use rose from 29% to 41%.PPS
- Urban Land Institute, Rose Center for Public Leadership and National League of Cities, Building Healthy Corridors: Transforming Urban and Suburban Arterials into Thriving Places, ch. 2Edgewater Drive carried more than 20,000 vehicles a day as a four-lane road, with a crash every three days. Orlando trialled the lane reduction in tape, measured it, and made it permanent in December 2002. Total collisions down 40% and injury rates down 71%; traffic counts briefly dropped 12% before returning to their original level; pedestrians up 23%, bicycling up 30%, on-street parking use up 41%; 77 new businesses and 560 jobs on the corridor since 2008; property values up 80% adjacent and 70% within half a mile; no requests to restore the four-lane road at the 2012 resurfacing.Excerpt
- Ford, “Roundabout Route,” NC State News, August 31, 2009George Chapman of the Hillsborough Street Partnership as construction started on the $9.2 million first phase, with 200 neighbourhood businesses on the street. The article also records 70 crashes in 2008 on the stretch then under construction, including four pedestrians and two cyclists struck.NC State News
- Project for Public Spaces, “Road Diet Case Study: A Safer, Better Hillsborough Street”Raleigh, North Carolina. Four lanes to two with four roundabouts, on-street parking, bicycle lanes and wider sidewalks, built from 2009. Vehicle crashes down 23%; new private investment along the corridor up from $150 million to $200 million; sidewalk mileage nearly doubled since 2013. Before the redesign, 32 pedestrian crashes were reported from 2004 to 2008 and 17 bicycle crashes from 2000 to 2006, more than 80% of them causing injury.PPS
- Project for Public Spaces, “Road Diet Case Study: Invigorating Ingersoll”; FHWA, Road Diet Case Studies: Ingersoll Avenue, Des Moines, IowaBusiness surveys before and after the 2010 trial; the six-month trial terms, the 50% crash reduction, and the Cityview editorial “Our View: Road diet makes Ingersoll fit,” November 18, 2010, quoted in FHWA’s case study.PPS · FHWA